Search OleOle:
enesptfritderuzhkoja Sign Up Log in
Home > FIFA > UEFA > Spain > La Liga > Real Madrid > RealmadridTalk > Who Should Real Madrid Sign: Tevez, Benzema, Huntelaar, Crespo or Villa?

« Previous Post Next Post »

Who Should Real Madrid Sign: Tevez, Benzema, Huntelaar, Crespo or Villa?

Sunday, 16 November 08, 03:01 PM · Comments (38)

Bernd Schuster

Schuster: Who Could Save My Ass?

There are many names mentioned in the press and new ones pop up everyday. I'm only going to talk about those who could move to a club like Real Madrid and not about those who dream and wish they could move to Real Madrid, those including Vanger Love and Amr Zaki (no offense though).

Alright, so lets start with Carlos Teves. He plays for Manchester United but since ever they signed Barbatov he hasn't played that much. He is fast, he has good dribbling skills, good ball control, but what I don't like about him is that he is inconsistent and his attitude on and off the pitch isn't that good.

Additionally, we are looking for one who should be as good as Ruud, someone who could play a similar role and in this case, Tevez isn't the ideal candidate.

Karim Benzema, on the other hand, can to some point do Ruud's job. He can play as a stand-alone striker, he is physically strong, talented and young so he could be used for short-term and long-term purposes, however, there is one problem and that is his club, Lyon.

Their president is a smart person who knows how to negotiate well. Benzema's buy-out-clause is approximately 50m euros and with competition from the likes of Barcelona, AC Milan and Chelsea, it would be pretty hard to sign him.

Maybe Real could instead try with Huantelaar. He is probably going to be a "RUUD Clone", tall, talented and experienced although he is still young. Ajax might be tempted with something like 20m or 30m euros and as long as I know, there isn't any serious competition. One advantage we might have is the fact we have five Dutch players.

To replace a very effective, world-class striker, it is logical to sign someone with the same characteristics and I can't think of anyone available but Crespo.

He isn't seeing much playing time at Inter Milan and we could sign him for short-term purpose. He is old yes, but he is a hell of a striker. He can do what Ruud can do, so I'd be happy to see him in the white shirt. Inter might let him go for 10m 0r 15m euros.

A very effective and YOUNG world-class striker is David Villa whom we tried to sign this summer, but due to Calderon being busy with pursuing Ronaldo, we failed. I prefer him over many others because he is Spanish, talented, experienced, fast and has a good attitude off and on the pitch. I wonder if Valencia would be willing to sell him even for 50m euros.

Anyway, I'd love to hear your thoughts on this.

Hala Madrid!

Like this blog? Help spread the word: Facebook Diggicon Reddit Delicious

38 Madridistas have commented on "Who Should Real Madrid Sign: Tevez, Benzema, Huntelaar, Crespo or Villa?" · Add yours

munited7
Spacer Spacer
0
1. munited7 Wrote: | 21.46GMT | Nov 16, 2008

Madrid need to not waste their money on top players. They need to TRAIN their OWN players from their ACADEMY! That is what it is there for. Leave other clubs alone! You are gonna go bankrupt!

josue
Spacer Spacer
0
2. josue Wrote: | 22.04GMT | Nov 16, 2008

Real madrid from what i saw in the summer were left with 140 million euros because of the sale of robinho and the money they raised for cristiano. So the problem is not the money we can splash out 50 million euros on benzema in the summer and also go for crisitano if he doent sign that new deal. But those two guys will not come until the summer if they do. So i think we need to go for a guy like crespo in the winter just for the short term and buy a centre back. Also i think real are favorites for benzema because we wont hesitate to splash out the money on him like other teams will like barca. Hala madrid

thedangerzolo
Spacer Spacer
0
3. thedangerzolo Wrote: | 22.07GMT | Nov 16, 2008

Reply to munited7:

Madrid need to not waste their money on top players. They need to TRAIN their OWN players from their ACADEMY! That is what it is there for. Leave other clubs alone! You are gonna go bankrupt!

I'd agree with you if we have a complete team right now but given the injuries on the team we need a solution

abdullatif
Spacer Spacer
0
4. abdullatif Wrote: | 22.13GMT | Nov 16, 2008

At first I want to say;I am one of Argentin national team supporter but if related to me no Tavez and Crespo I will take Benzema or Villa whatever they cost espcialy Villa who know spanish league very well.

davorreal
Spacer Spacer
0
5. davorreal Wrote: | 22.20GMT | Nov 16, 2008

Reply to munited7:

Madrid need to not waste their money on top players. They need to TRAIN their OWN players from their ACADEMY! That is what it is there for. Leave other clubs alone! You are gonna go bankrupt!

You are right and we have already some good boys who will become big stars one day,I hope!But if big talents like Benzema say that he would like to play here what would You do?Refuse?BTW MUFC is also very interesting in him!So that is not the problem,the whole history of RealMadrid shows that biggest players come here because they want to play here!

realfreak
Spacer Spacer
0
6. realfreak Wrote: | 23.09GMT | Nov 16, 2008

For now I say give the young guys a chance....they are working their asses off to make the 1st team, and every year that goes by real go out and buy big name players and then sell their young talent to other teams with a clause preventing them from playing against us....WHY? If they make us so fearful that we don't want them to play against us....why sell? I am no ManU fan but I always give Sir Alex props for making stars out of and trusting "no name" players. See what the young guns can do and them over the summer if the need arise spend. You think they had to go buy gago and Higuain years ago? no....they could've gotton those positions in the youth team. How many players can you name since the raul/Guti/Casillas generation have come up in the ranks?

madridtrini4
Spacer Spacer
0
7. madridtrini4 Wrote: | 23.34GMT | Nov 16, 2008

madrid need another argentine.. or just a south american.. what about falcao? hez a superb striker, he can dribble, he will score goals.. he is very similar to kun aguero.. what about pablo aimar? he isnt a striker, but he can and will score goals. he needs a big club to reshow his worth, and get recalled for argentina..

pablo
Spacer Spacer
0
8. pablo Wrote: | 23.36GMT | Nov 16, 2008

Reply to realfreak:

For now I say give the young guys a chance....they are working their asses off to make the 1st team, and every year that goes by real go out and buy big name players and then sell their young talent to other teams with a clause preventing them from playing against us....WHY? If they make us so...

for that same reason i think Schuster should be fired ....real madrid need a coach with that talant like Sir Alex to get the best and make stars out of and trusting "no name" players...the players alway saying Schuster don't talk to them and you can see that is true because the palyer is not inproving under Schuster ...it's ok been a tough guy like Schuster....but team with so much young players they need a coach that they can talk too..

madridtrini4
Spacer Spacer
0
9. madridtrini4 Wrote: | 23.37GMT | Nov 16, 2008

from castilla, there are lots of talented entertaining players.. two gr8 strikers are bueno and szalai.. szalai should also be called up to the 1s team.. barca took a chance with bojan, now he iz superb.. messi was also about 18 when he debuted.. whats taking madrid soo long to give their youth teamers a chance?

morzzan
Spacer Spacer
0
10. morzzan Wrote: | 23.45GMT | Nov 16, 2008

Yes, as some people pointed out, we can look into our youth academy till the winter window reopens. We must get a striker from the youth academy to fill that void which is plaguing our team.
And from the names listed, we must definitely get Tevez. I feel he is one of the most wonderful players out there, his work rate is phenomenal, and he can play just behind the striker and that will effectively put an end to Raul's game and restrict him to being a substitute. I feel the very link of Crespo to Madrid made me sick and sad, I feel that he is a sad player, hasn't been very successful and not the kind of player we need. We need someone who can be quick, 25+-2 years of age and not european. Someone who can play in the Champions League. And for some reason, I feel that we should have brought Huntelaar this year. We definitely should have brought him, Garay needs to be brought back in January, we need to strengthen that defense. I wouldn't be surprised if we see 2 defenders come in! Pepe has been aweful, all season, so has Heinze. Cannavaro has not been good either, and lets not talk about Ramos' antiques. He is my favorite player in the madrid shirt at the present time, but looking at his form, we definitely need reinforcements in defense.

REDS/N/BLUES
Spacer Spacer
0
11. REDS/N/BLUES Wrote: | 00.49GMT | Nov 17, 2008

NOWAY IN HELL YOU GUYS WILL GET THE CL CUP BACK WITH SUCH PLAYERS AGAIN THIS TEAM SHOULD BE SOLD IN STOCK MARKET , WONDER IF ATLETICO MADRID HAD THEIR HANDS ON A PORTION OF YOUR CASH HOW WOULD THEY LOOK LIKE ???? OFFCOARSE BETTER THAN YOU P.s U ONLY TAKE THE LIGA WHEN BARCA IS NOT PERFOMRING WELL , AS FOR THE CHAMPIONS LEAGUE DONT U EVER DREAM OF GETTING SUCH PRESTIGIOUS TROPHY MADRIDO U NEED LEGENS LIKE DI STEPHANO AND ZIZO and thats about it ...
BIT ME MADRID , wish i c u guys in the champions league next year make sure u rank 4th or smtn this year and my money is that ull be knocked out from zenit and bate ....
whore madrid !!!

Dridian
Spacer Spacer
0
12. Dridian Wrote: | 02.36GMT | Nov 17, 2008

Reply to REDS/N/BLUES:

NOWAY IN HELL YOU GUYS WILL GET THE CL CUP BACK WITH SUCH PLAYERS AGAIN THIS TEAM SHOULD BE SOLD IN STOCK MARKET , WONDER IF ATLETICO MADRID HAD THEIR HANDS ON A PORTION OF YOUR CASH HOW WOULD THEY LOOK LIKE ???? OFFCOARSE BETTER THAN YOU P.s U ONLY TAKE THE LIGA WHEN BARCA IS NOT PERFOMRING WELL ,...

Somewhere in your heart i know u love Real Madrid.... Don't worry my friend although you are not worthy to eat at Real royal table you can have the crumbs....... But there are certain points mentioned here that are really good, like Real promoting there youth players..... That's why i am still convinced we need to hire a Latin coach......[Spain, Portugal or South America] who understands our system and style of play, see Barca promoted there B team coach and he is not doing that bad,,, because he understands the latin system and style of play.... And the best of all those mentioned is Tevez, but then again it would be hard to play Tevez, Sneijder, and vandervaart altogether, because all these players like to roam and all are comfortable behind a main striker,, so there goes team balance so Benzema would be great, I guess Saviola is not that good, i don't know??... But i still insist we need a playmaker.... When you name the big clubs in Europe you can tell a player name who stands out well on that team... When i hear Real Madrid i can't name one player who i can say he is the MAN OR PLAYMAKER,, maybe its Guti, i don't know???

MadridIndo
Spacer Spacer
0
13. MadridIndo Wrote: | 04.54GMT | Nov 17, 2008

The best choice should have been either Benzema or Villa. Both of them play consistently in their respective club. Benzema is simply amazing. yes, we all know that it would be a hard struggle to get him but the price will be worthed. he's young, talented, and he will reach a glorious peak performance, if he is in the proper team, which is for me, Madrid of course. the other one should be Villa. Can't say anything abouty him. you all can sewe by yourself. He's completely a monster in front of net. the only thing that might affect his productivity is injury, but i think he's not a "crystal-type' player. But, Seeing his great performance in the few games ago, i think it would be har for Madrid to recruit him. Valncia will surely protect him with all the best they can do. The other candidates is a good player, has their owwn unique, ability and advantage, but the ones that fulfill the quality of a Madrid center forward are only Villa and Benzema, but the one that still disturb my mind if we buy a new striker is about higuain. if he kept played not in his best position, he might considered to leave, which is clearly a great loss for Madrid, and Madrid should prevent that. Hala Madrid!!!

MadridIndo
Spacer Spacer
0
14. MadridIndo Wrote: | 05.12GMT | Nov 17, 2008

but the idea of promoting castilla player is a very good one. i've been saying that in my recent comments, and people are aying that Bueno is a good one, so why should we keep hiding him? Barcelona might say that Bojan is a wonderkid, and we should prove to the world that we can produce a wonder kid too!!!

chico
Spacer Spacer
0
15. chico Wrote: | 06.01GMT | Nov 17, 2008

pls note:castilla is the only undefeated team in spai and what on earth is schuster doing playing canna and heinze who have no hope?....i say, play the the entire castilla back 4. we may just find a star ther like fabio found torres......wenger would be ideal.

....and what is bueno doing on the bench.....drop raul for him

hala madrid!!!

Daniel
Spacer Spacer
0
16. Daniel Wrote: | 06.33GMT | Nov 17, 2008

Obviously...Benzema and Villa would be the best solutions...however they are both near-impossible targets.Therefore I beleive that what shoud Real do is buy Julio Cruz in the window transfer market (which would cost around 3m only)...and promote Bueno to the first team.However I DO repeat that Real need a winger not an attacker.Maybe Capel or Sweinstiger would be a good singing.So I think that overall we should buy Cruz,Capel and bring back Garay.And the players who should leave: Saviola(because Schuster doesn't like him),Heinze and maybe Metzelder ;)

TheAngelOfMadrid
Spacer Spacer
0
17. TheAngelOfMadrid Wrote: | 09.00GMT | Nov 17, 2008

Benzema, Villa and Tevez should be the shortlist though out of these my favourite for the type of striker we currently need is VIlla. He runs, dribbles and scores. We need more than just a damn strikers, we need to either make Diarra play more matches or sign another holding midfield player who's a pain to get past. We should also recalll Garay and sign Cheillini. And for cover on the wings, there's Capel or Di Maria. But even without these players we have the talent, the players it seems are afraid to use it :? But one player who really gets on my nerve is Heinze, WTF is he even there for, all he does is get womped by the wingers of other teams and get involved in silly things which cost us. At this rate, you can expect Barcelona to get some payback for our 4-1 against them last year. Another thing, the problem is NOT Schuster, it's the people around him who havn't given him what he wants and technically it's Mijatovic's responsibility to listen to him whereas he doesn't give a shit. I think that this is just bad run of form and as soon as we start winning again and get our players back, everything should be back to normal. Hala Madrid! :|

Rireal
Spacer Spacer
0
18. Rireal Wrote: | 11.48GMT | Nov 17, 2008

What about Frank Ribery as a right winger? or Dario Srna?

Rireal
Spacer Spacer
0
19. Rireal Wrote: | 11.52GMT | Nov 17, 2008

Srna is a player who plays very good on a right wing in his national team and also very good as a right back in his club... He is talented and very useful player

arlind
Spacer Spacer
0
20. arlind Wrote: | 12.20GMT | Nov 17, 2008

Now real madrid are interested in shevchenko -4-

???
Spacer Spacer
0
21. ??? Wrote: | 12.40GMT | Nov 17, 2008

Reply to REDS/N/BLUES:

NOWAY IN HELL YOU GUYS WILL GET THE CL CUP BACK WITH SUCH PLAYERS AGAIN THIS TEAM SHOULD BE SOLD IN STOCK MARKET , WONDER IF ATLETICO MADRID HAD THEIR HANDS ON A PORTION OF YOUR CASH HOW WOULD THEY LOOK LIKE ???? OFFCOARSE BETTER THAN YOU P.s U ONLY TAKE THE LIGA WHEN BARCA IS NOT PERFOMRING WELL ,...

FUCK U!

Walker
Spacer Spacer
0
22. Walker Wrote: | 12.43GMT | Nov 17, 2008

In my opinion, we don't really need a striker. We should just give Saviola more of a chance. Even with Ruud & Robben out we have enough players who can score goals both upfront and in midfield and scoring goals this season hasn't really been as much of a problem. The defence is where our big problems lie.

None of players at the back, even Ramos and Pepe have been consistantly good enough this season. I think a big reason for this is that Schuster hasn't regularly used the same back four. When Pepe returns to the side, Schuster should play Ramos, Pepe, Cannavaro and Marcelo in the back four and stick with it, especially the two central defenders. This would give them time to gel. Obviously you always have to rest players as well as give others a chance, but squad rotation every other game is rarely good.
HALA MADRID!!!

Riken
Spacer Spacer
0
23. Riken Wrote: | 13.26GMT | Nov 17, 2008

I think Huntelaar or Benzema would be perfect for Madrid, first of all they are young players and got skills.I don`t think we should go for Crespo becuase he is old and he will not play for long time, and we should look for the future.

realfreak
Spacer Spacer
0
24. realfreak Wrote: | 13.33GMT | Nov 17, 2008

TIIC at real should've been fielding the young guys long ago so by January they would've known if they needed to go and buy anyone. Why spend millions on mid-20 and near 30 y.o. players when you have under 20 ones who are just as good. Save the money for the summer.

Adambader
Spacer Spacer
0
25. Adambader Wrote: | 14.34GMT | Nov 17, 2008

Reply to munited7:

Madrid need to not waste their money on top players. They need to TRAIN their OWN players from their ACADEMY! That is what it is there for. Leave other clubs alone! You are gonna go bankrupt!

Agree but we are here looking for a READY replacement not one that we'd train. Still, I think Real need to have a better management team for our youth academy and also show some confidence in our young players.

Adambader
Spacer Spacer
0
26. Adambader Wrote: | 14.40GMT | Nov 17, 2008

Reply to madridtrini4:

madrid need another argentine.. or just a south american.. what about falcao? hez a superb striker, he can dribble, he will score goals.. he is very similar to kun aguero.. what about pablo aimar? he isnt a striker, but he can and will score goals. he needs a big club to reshow his worth, and get...

The myth that anyone who comes from South America is talented is pure "crap". It is true there are many talents in South America, however, there are also talented players not only from Europe but also from Africa.

As for Aimar, I don't think Real would ever consider him. We already have Sneijder, VDV and Guti who all could play in his position.

Carlyluvsunited
Spacer Spacer
0
27. Carlyluvsunited Wrote: | 18.37GMT | Nov 17, 2008

It makes me laugh my ass off the way Real Madrid and their fans talk !!

Number one: The player must have a desire to play for Madrid, you don't just decide "OK, we'll buy him, him and him now".

Fergie showed Real Madrid they aren't the only football team in the world like they seem to think they are !!!

If Real want to but Cristiano Ronaldo they should keep their mouths shut and United will tell them when they can have him.

If they now want Tevez, then the same rules apply. General Franco is gone now and Real Madrid are about 5th in the pecking order in Europe despite thinking they are number one !! They are number one at nothing, nothing at all, except maybe having a big ego and suffering from narcisism.

Adambader
Spacer Spacer
0
28. Adambader Wrote: | 20.46GMT | Nov 17, 2008

Reply to Walker:

In my opinion, we don't really need a striker. We should just give Saviola more of a chance. Even with Ruud & Robben out we have enough players who can score goals both upfront and in midfield and scoring goals this season hasn't really been as much of a problem. The defence is where our big...

Well-said. Agreed. ;)

Adambader
Spacer Spacer
0
29. Adambader Wrote: | 20.47GMT | Nov 17, 2008

Reply to Riken:

I think Huntelaar or Benzema would be perfect for Madrid, first of all they are young players and got skills.I don`t think we should go for Crespo becuase he is old and he will not play for long time, and we should look for the future.

Yes but don't you think we could use him just in the short-term?

Adambader
Spacer Spacer
0
30. Adambader Wrote: | 20.52GMT | Nov 17, 2008

Reply to Carlyluvsunited:

It makes me laugh my ass off the way Real Madrid and their fans talk !!

Number one: The player must have a desire to play for Madrid, you don't just decide "OK, we'll buy him, him and him now".

Fergie showed Real Madrid they aren't the only football team in the world like...

Yeah but at least Real Madrid fans don't stab people in the back ... the manutdtalk.com and your story? Eh, I feel bad for you, you must have spent a lot of hours working your ass-off.

Talking of ass, I love your photos =D

davorreal
Spacer Spacer
0
31. davorreal Wrote: | 20.54GMT | Nov 17, 2008

No! We are not the only team in the world,but we still are the best one!And this is not a narcism this is the truth!
Where was Franco when we won 3 CL 10 years ago?Fergi shoots the wrong target!I remember the CL Moscow final!Some of United fans said:Believe!We also believe now however down we are!

hassona60
Spacer Spacer
0
32. hassona60 Wrote: | 21.34GMT | Nov 17, 2008

I VOTE FOR: best to least
1- DAVID VILLA
2- CRESPO
3- HUNTELAAR
4- BENZEMA

THANK YOU

REDS/N/BLUES
Spacer Spacer
0
33. REDS/N/BLUES Wrote: | 23.59GMT | Nov 17, 2008

Reply to Carlyluvsunited:

It makes me laugh my ass off the way Real Madrid and their fans talk !!

Number one: The player must have a desire to play for Madrid, you don't just decide "OK, we'll buy him, him and him now".

Fergie showed Real Madrid they aren't the only football team in the world like...

number one : ITS NO1z fault mrs curly that half of your squad wants to join us for some reason .
number 2 : fergie did show us somethings really important that your so called "red devils" will not survive if mr nancy ronaldo took a hike :D
number 3 : bayb he was givin us signals i want madrid i want madrid mayb hez soo sick of man and fergie depending on him everymatch u know cuz we all know MAN U is shit without NANCY ronaldo u know it i know it .
number 4 : keep up the good work train your players real good and give us a call when their smtn worth talking about .. cuz at the end MAN U is ntn but a commercial team running after CASH ..... u feel me RED PEACA SHIT DEVil

P.s stop talking from your ass cupcake and go blog on fergiez board way 2 go GUNNERS

Dridian
Spacer Spacer
0
34. Dridian Wrote: | 00.13GMT | Nov 18, 2008

I will take Huntelaar any day over Benzema

abu zidane
Spacer Spacer
0
35. abu zidane Wrote: | 19.43GMT | Dec 23, 2008

i will like madrid to sign tevez.because he is a strogle play maker.and he has the talent of pushing atack,he is also a speed run player.infant tevez has every thing that a coach need and the fas.please you shouid the great agentina striker.


Digitalis83
Spacer Spacer
0
36. Digitalis83 Wrote: | 02.18GMT | Dec 24, 2008

Nothing would make me happier then if they signed Villa... Favorite player on my favorite team. :D

kaboggoza emmanuel
Spacer Spacer
0
37. kaboggoza emmanuel Wrote: | 07.00GMT | Jan 29, 2009

let madrid sign villa instead of tevez and case raul in the team

omar bah
Spacer Spacer
0
38. omar bah Wrote: | 20.48GMT | Feb 23, 2009

letreal madrid buy david villa,tevez and benzema let dreanteh go away

Leave a comment




(Don’t want to see this next time? Just sign up for an account.)
To contact Adam, send an email to rajab (at) oleole.com | RealmadridTalk.com - By Adam Bader